Following on from the last blog about reading. I thought about the types of questions I would ask my EAL readers, or indeed other readers, about the books they have read. Most questions need to be open questions otherwise the reader doesnt have the opportunity to tell you what they gained from the book. There is nothing worse than 30 replies of my book was …… written by ….. I liked it …..because and then the reason doesnt really show you what they have enjoyed, liked etc. This set of questions is just here to help you stretch them and give you some ideas. If you have further suggestions please add to the comments.
After starting off with finding out the name of the book and author, find out what the book was generally about and if they have been taught about genres what genre/style is it e.g. mystery. If they have been on an end of term break you could ask where they read the book, in bed, outside on the grass, on the beach etc.
Then to encourage further discussion
- How different was it to how you thought it would be before you read it? … some choose books from pictures on the front and then find the story doesn’t match at all.
- Was the cover a good cover to let you know what the story was about?
- For more advanced readers was the book as good as the back cover details led you to believe?
- Did you want to read it right to the end ….if not what made them feel this way but what kept them going if they did… I was given the Water Babies by Charles Kingsley as a child after an operation in hospital. I couldn’t read it then and havent been too since as it all seems to far-fetched, although I have tried many times I get as far as the chimney sweeps and that’s it .
- What was your favourite part of the book? This may be a line, a character, a part of the story try to draw out as much information as possible.
- Is it like a story or stories you have read before? …..maybe they have read a similar series or style
- What caught your attention? …we often tell them that the first line must when writing, but it is not necessarily the same when reading ? It may have been something much further through the book.
- Which bits didn’t you like? ….this gives you further ideas of the types of books they may enjoy and ones to start to drop.
- What was your favourite character? Why
- What character didn’t you like? Why
- Did you read the bits you didn’t like? …… If it is gory I don’t.
- Did it remind you of a celebration you celebrate ?(i.e.)This may help draw out something about their cultural background
- What was different about this book … if it’s a series has one of the characters shown a different side to their character, is the adventure in a different land which is different to either this country or the previous country they lived in?
- Would you read books from this author again? Why/Why not ….I did love Enid Blyton and the adventures of the characters, probably why I like Agatha Christie’s Poirot in adult life.
- What made you think about the book now you have finished it … they may have liked it so much they want to read more or it was so awful they don’t want to read similar stories again. My daughter was sent home from school with the book ‘There a monster under my bed’. We duly helped her read it but at 20 we all still remember the nightmares it gave her because it made her think there may be something under the bed?
- Take the first line of the book and create a whole new paragraph for a new story
- Take their favourite line and use it to create a mini story
- Take their favourite character and write a character profile
- Reset the story in another setting e.g. if they come from or speak Chinese set in China what differences would that make to the story?
- If they were the author show the changes they would make to make it better… this could be as simple as a new title or more in-depth by adding a new character.
For older children or more advanced readers
- Take a children’s author e.g. Enid Blyton and compare with a similar Adult author e.g. Agatha Christie and look at the similarities in the plot , characters, locations etc.
- Write a short synopsis to replace the information o the back cover of the book
- Find out the authors history and work out what aspects of this are within their work e.g. location, if they worked in a tax office maybe the story is set within this industry etc.